A holding co agency sits inside one of the big global holding companies. It brings scale, global systems and buying set at group level, and it's built to serve large, multi-market advertisers.
An independent agency answers to no one but its clients. There's no group strategy to fit into, no global platform to use and no head office deciding where the money goes. The plan is shaped by your business, and nothing else.
Neither is wrong. They're built for different clients, and the question is which one is built for you.
A challenger is up against bigger, better-funded competitors. Your budget is tighter, every dollar has to work, and you need to be noticed, not just present.
That calls for an agency that moves at your pace, thinks about your category in particular and treats your account as a priority. In a holding co, a challenger's budget sits alongside some of the largest advertisers in the country, and it's fair to ask where you'll rank when time and senior attention are being handed out.
This is the question that matters most, and it's the one most often skipped.
The people who pitch aren't always the people who do the work. Ask who'll run your account day to day, who'll make the strategic calls and who'll be in your monthly meetings. Then get it in writing.
At an independent, it's usually the senior people you met in the pitch. Whoever it is, you want people who've worked with businesses at your stage and who'll still be there in a year.
Listen to the first conversation. If the agency is talking about TV, social or programmatic before it understands your margins, your customers and your competitors, it's working backwards.
A good agency asks about the business first: what you need to grow, where the sales come from, what's holding you back. The channel mix follows the strategy. It should never be the strategy.
Ask them to walk you through how they've approached a business like yours, and what they'd do differently for a brand launching compared with one defending its share.
Reach, frequency and cost per thousand tell you whether the media ran. They don't tell you whether it worked.
The right agency ties the work to the numbers you report on: sales, leads, cost per acquisition, share of market. Ask how they'll report, how often, and what they'll recommend when something isn't working. A report that only shows what was delivered isn't enough.
Keep it tight. Write a clear brief with your goals for the next 12 months and what success looks like, then invite a short list of three to five agencies. Too many agencies and the responses get thinner.
Judge them on the questions they ask as much as the answers they give. Watch how quickly they respond, whether they've done their homework on your category, and whether the senior people in the room will still be in the room after you sign.
Yes. If you're a large advertiser running coordinated campaigns across several countries, a holding co's global reach and systems can do a real job for you. For a brand focused on Australia, it's worth asking whether you need that scale or will end up paying for it.
Three to five. A short list gets you more considered responses, respects the agencies' time and makes the comparison easier for you. Include both independent and holding co agencies if you want to compare the two.
Your media buying agency should help you make better decisions about where, when and how to spend your advertising money. Read more...
Chosen your agency? Here's what should happen in the first 90 days, from the commercial groundwork to the first results. Read more...
